The planters punch is a classic tiki cocktail, and its been around so long that theres as many variations on it as there are mixologists, it seems. Our favorite is gaz regans citrus-heavy recipe, but this stripped-down interpretation from don the beachcomber comes in a close second. The original recipe, as printed in beachbum berrys grog log calls for a dark jamaican rum and a light puerto rican rum. The rums you choose are a matter of personal taste; dons own planters is such a well-crafted recipe that itll bring out the best in any rum you already enjoy.