Share
Tallahassee’s pizza scenario will introduce you to new and innovative takes on the dishes that still reflect the tradition in every bite. In numerous places, you will find intriguing menus featuring pizzas from every region in the US. Whether you want to try the authentic Neapolitan pizza from Italy or savour contemporary New York-style pizza, these pizza places in Tallahassee will serve you anything you ask for.
Strolling down the vibrant streets, you will come across some inviting eateries with beautiful decor and a delightful menu featuring your favourite pizza. Whether you are looking for some expertly cooked pizza or want to build your pizzas, these restaurants will give you an experience that you will never find elsewhere.
Cosy places like Gaines Street Pies will greet you with a huge smile and help you indulge in their signature piping hot pizzas. While bustling stops like Momo's Pizza will give you an exciting experience in the unassuming quaint neighbourhood. When in Tallahassee, you can’t miss these top pizza spots.
7 Pizza Places In Tallahassee To Explore
1) Momo's Pizza
Momo's Pizza is a renowned pizza destination in Tallahassee that serves pizzas by the pie or huge slice. With multiple locations across the city, Momo’s keep the menu straight in every outlet. Their wide selection of pizzas is available at affordable prices. The famous pizzas include Slices as Big as Your Head pizza which is a huge pizza slice. Recommended options like Vegan Cheese, Vegan slices, and Hand-Thrown Pizzas with a variety of toppings are a must-try.
Location: 1416 W Tennessee St, Tallahassee, FL 32304, United States
Timings: Sun-Thu: 11 am–10 pm; Fri-Sat: 11 am–11 pm
Must Try: Slices as Big as Your Head, Vegan Cheese, Vegan slices, and Hand-Thrown Pizzas
Price for 2: $40 approx.
Image Credit: Momo's Pizza | Facebook
2) Decent Pizza
Decent Pizza is often called “Perfect Pizza” place by the locals. This no-frills establishment specialises in New York York-style pizzas and has a huge build-your-own menu with a variety of toppings. Bringing the flavour of New York to Florioda since 2003, Decent Pizza has become a local landmark in the city. Guests often rave about the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Garlic Knots. As per the menu, their signature dishes include Supreme Pizza with mozzarella cheese and Italian sausage and Veg Head and Meat Head pizzas.
Location: 1026 N Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States
Timings: Mon-Sat: 11 am–10 pm; Sun: 4–9 pm
Must Try: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Garlic Knots, Supreme Pizza
Price for 2: $40 approx.
Image Credit: Decent Pizza
3) Gaines Street Pies
Located near Florida State University, Gaines Street Pies serves up delicious, customizable pizzas with a variety of toppings to choose from. They also offer vegan and gluten-free options, making it a great choice for those with dietary restrictions. Their menu features craft brews and a variety of sandwiches, wraps & appetizers along with pizza. Recommended dishes to try are Pesto Chicken Pizza, The Temptation Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, and Vegetarian Pizza. You should also try the beverages and appetisers for a complete meal.
Location: 603 W Gaines St #3, Tallahassee, FL 32304, United States
Timings: Sun-Thu: 11 am–1 am; Fri-Sat: 11 am–2 am
Must Try: Pesto Chicken Pizza, The Temptation Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, and Vegetarian Pizza
Price for 2: $40 approx.
4) Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is a counter-serve pizza place located in Boston City Palace. It is renowned for its crispy, thin-crust pies and variety of toppings and sauces. They craft their pizzas from scratch and always stick to the freshest ingredients. From healthful artisanal options to timeless classics, every pizza is fast-fire'd in their blazing hot oven by dedicated pizzasmiths, ensuring perfection in just 180 seconds. Since it's a BYOB menu, you can craft your own pizza masterpieces and get them on your table piping hot.
Location: 220 S Magnolia Dr, Tallahassee, FL 32301, United States
Timings: Mon-Sun: 11 am–10:30 pm
Must Try: Build Your Own Pizza
Price for 2: $50 approx.
Also Read: 7 Must-Try Indian Restaurants Kansas City
5) Bagigio’s
Bagigio’s is located in the woods of North Florida's Big Bend, south of downtown Tallahassee. Their pizzas bring true Italian flavours to every slice. This restaurant showcases craftsmanship in every aspect of its dishes. Bagigio's Menu constantly updates with fresh ideas and ingredients, so you will always get to see a changing menu as per the season. They prepare their pizzas with cold fermented dough made with Artisan Flour, Celtic Sea Salt and Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil. The highlights on the menu include Italian Pizza, Stromboli and Calzones.
Location: 8954 Woodville Hwy Tallahassee, FL 32305, United States
Timings: Mon-Tue: Closed; Wed-Sat: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Sun: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Must Try: Italian Pizza, Stromboli and Calzones
Price for 2: $50 approx.
Image Credit: Bagigio’s
6) Village Pizza & Pasta
Village Pizza & Pasta is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant. It is known for offering New York-style pizzas, pasta, and other Italian dishes. All the pizzas are baked in real brick ovens for authentic taste. Their menu includes a variety of options such as calzones, pasta, seafood, salads, soups, strombolis, subs, wings, and desserts. Along with this, a selection of wines is also available. Their dough is made from scratch daily, hand-tossed, and topped with fresh vegetables, quality meats, and cheeses. Recommended dishes to try are New York-style pizza and Sicilian pizza.
Location: 1400 Village Square Blvd #33, Tallahassee, FL 32312, United States
Timings: Sun-Tue: 11 am–9 pm; Wed-Sat: 11 am–10 pm
Must Try: New York-style pizza and Sicilian pizza
Price for 2: $40 approx.
7) Red Elephant Pizza & Grill
Red Elephant is a lively, family-friendly restaurant known for grilled American entrees and classic favourites like pizza, burgers, and wings. For over ten years, this restaurant has been a family favourite for the locals. Their food-to-order dishes ensure freshness in every bite. The homemade essence in every dish draws the best flavours. You also get vegan and gluten-free options on the menu. Dishes like Italian sausage pizza, House Salad and Fries are highly recommended.
Location: 2910 Kerry Forest Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32309, United States
Timings: Sun-Thu: 11 am–8 pm; Fri-Sat: 11 am–9 pm
Must Try: Italian sausage pizza, House Salad and Fries
Price for 2: $50 approx.
Image Credit: Red Elephant Pizza & Grill
Whether you want to savour true Italian flavours or indulge in modern American delicacy, these pizza places in Tallahassee ensure a delightful repast for you. These longstanding restaurants have been serving the best flavours in the city and became a landmark that you should not miss while touring in the city.
