Share
When craving pizza in Colorado Springs, it's easy to get overwhelmed with the tons of choices available. While the city may not be as flourished as big cities like New York or Chicago, you will still find pizzerias that serve unmatched flavours topped with the best crust.
From New York-style pizza to Chicago deep-dish pizza, the pizzerias in Colorado Springs serve everything to satisfy your cravings. Using local and fresh ingredients, these pizzeria make high-quality bread and sauces which is what makes the pizzas so delicious.
Authentic Pizza places like Louie's Pizza are known for their unchanged recipe that gives the taste of heritage in every slice. The new havens like Walter's 303 are renowned for their eccentric vibes that make the experience enjoyable. Read more to know where you’ll get the best pizza in Colorado Springs.
7 Amazing Pizza Spots In Colorado Springs
1) Pizzeria Rustica
Image Credit: Pizzeria Rustica
Pizzeria Rustica uses only quality and local ingredients to create its masterpieces. Situated in Old Colorado City, this restaurant Has been rated as the Nation's top-rated Restaurant. It has also been certified as a Green Restaurant for its Eco-conscious ethos. The menu presents rich and traditional flavours from locally sourced produce with authentic Italian ingredients. Their wood-fired Neapolitan Pizzas are raved by hundreds of customers. Recommended dishes like Pizza, Insalata Caprese, Margherita, and Pizza Margherita are a must-try at this place.
Location: 2527 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80904
Timings: Mon-Thu: 5–9 pm; Fri-Sun: 12–10 pm
Must Try: Pizza, Insalata Caprese, Margherita, Caprese, Pizza Margherita
Price for 2: $40 approx.
2) Louie's Pizza
Image Credit: Michael Clark Via Google Maps
Since 1986, Louie's Pizza has been a cherished spot for pizza lovers in Colorado Springs. After the original owners retired, the new generation is operating the restaurant, promising the same taste of heritage that this place is known for. This restaurant is conveniently located in five regions across the city, so you’ll never be far away from tasting their pizza pies. Unique dishes on the menu like the taco pizza and La Fruita Pizza have gained so much praise from customers. Don't miss out on their legendary cheesy bread—your taste buds will thank you later.
Location: 333 N Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Timings: Sun-Thu: 11 am–10 pm; Fri-Sat: 11 am–12 am
Must Try: Taco Pizza, La Fruita Pizza, Cheesy Bread
Price for 2: $40 approx.
3) Slice420
Image Credit; Slice420
Slice420 isn't just about pizza, it's more a mission to help American Medical Refugees. This family-owned gem has roots from Florida to Colorado and is known for its New York-style pies. The owners came up with the unique concept of helping Medical Refugees after being inspired by their daughter who is battling Quad Spastic Cerebral Palsy. Through their pizzeria, they raise awareness and support for families like theirs. On the menu, you will find dishes like Garlic Knots, The Works, The Reaper, The Sofia, Buffalo Chicken, The Colorado, Garlic Rolls, and XL 18 Cheese Pizza and can opt for by-the-slice options as well.
Location: : 2501 W Colorado Ave #108, Colorado Springs, CO 80904
Timings: Sun: 12–9 pm; Mon: Closed; Tue-Thu: 10:30 am–9 pm; Fri-Sat: 10:30 am–10 pm
Must Try: Garlic Knots, The Works, The Reaper, The Sofia, Buffalo Chicken, The Colorado, Garlic Rolls, The Sophia, Cannoli, XL 18 Cheese Pizza, Mountain Man Pizza, Salads
Price for 2: $50 approx.
4) White Pie
Image Credit: White Pie
White Pie is known for serving New Haven-style pizza in downtown Colorado Springs. This cheerful and fine-tuned restaurant creates the best hand-tossed pizza with a thin crust and delectable sauces. Apart from pizza, you will get a wholesome brunch menu with roasted cauliflower, salads and cannolis and also happy-hour eats along with selected cocktails. The White Pie Pizza and Spicy G are some of the recommended dishes that you should not miss. Their signature White Pie pizza is made with crème fraîche, mushrooms, bacon, garlic, and mozzarella, and is topped off with a sunny-side-up egg in the centre.
Location: 330 S Nevada Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Timings: Mon-Fri: 11 am–10 pm; Sat-Sun: 10 am–9 pm
Must Try: White Pie pizza, Spicy G
Price for 2: $50 approx.
5) Walter's303
Image Credit: Walter's303
Walter's 303 is known for its deep-dish pizza with overwhelming toppings that one just can't get enough of. opening in 2010, Walter's 303 has flourished across the Front Range drawing people with their "Always Funky, Never Dull" vibe to urbanites and suburbanites alike. You will find this place filled with pizza enthusiasts all year round. Along with Deep dish pizza try the cauliflower crust pizza, Cheese bread and craft beers.
Location: 2690 North Gate Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80921
Timings: Sun: 11 am–9 pm; Mon: 4–9 pm; Tue-Thu: 11 am–9 pm; Fri-Sat: 11 am–10 pm
Must Try: Deep Dish Pizza, Cauliflower Crust Pizza, Cheese Bread
Price for 2: $40 approx.
6) Fat Sully’s
Image Credit: Fat Sully’s
Fat Sully’s Will serve you the best New York-style pizza with a thin crust, loaded toppings and homemade sauces. Fat Sully’s is the sister restaurant of Denver Biscuit Co established by Atomic Cowboy. Their pizzas are so giant that you'll need two plates to hold it up. Their massive 26” pie is perfect for the entire family. Along with the New York-style pizza, also try the waffle fries, mushroom gravy, Nashville hot chicken, and garlic knots.
Location: 528 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Timings: Sun-Thu: 8 am–12 am; Fri-Sat: 8 am–2 am
Must Try: Giant Pepperoni Pizza 26 Inch, Waffle Fries, Mushroom Gravy, Nashville Hot Chicken, And Garlic Knots
Price for 2: $40 approx.
7) Fargo's Pizza
Image Credit: Fargo's Pizza
Fargo's Pizza has been serving flavourful Pizza since 1973. The restaurant, founded by brothers Leon and Landon, is inspired by Fargo and Sophia, a mountain legend. Fargo's is located in a large Victorian Old West saloon and equipped with a self-playing piano. Their massive dining space can hold up to 500 people at one time. Their extensive menu offers 25 diverse pizza options, so you'll always enjoy exploring new flavours all the time. Try the recommended Fargo's Favorite Pizza and Salad Bar upon your visit.
Location: 2910 E Platte Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80909
Timings: Mon-Thu: 11 am–8 pm; Fri-Sun: 11 am–9 pm
Must Try: Fargo's Favorite Pizza and Salad Bar
Price for 2: $70 approx.
Savour the best pizza in Colorado Springs in these seven amazing restaurants. Whether you like the taste of heritage or want to try a new adventure, these places will give you the best experience you can ever imagine.
