From Fowl to Feast: A Culinary Journey Through Thanksgiving’s Evolution

THANKSGIVING isn’t just about gratitude—it’s also about gluttony, glorious gluttony. This holiday, the table groans under a banquet that blends centuries of tradition with trends as fleeting as a perfectly puffed soufflé. But what did the Pilgrims really eat? When did canned cranberry sauce debut? And how did marshmallows crash the party? Follow us through the timeline of the Thanksgiving meal, where we serve up the history, trivia, and a sprinkling of puzzles along the way. (Warning: May induce cravings.)

1621: The First Thanksgiving

Dishes likely served: Wildfowl (duck, goose), venison, seafood (lobster, clams), corn porridge, squash, beans.

Missing in action: Turkey, pie, and cranberry sauce.

🎵 Trivia Puzzle: This dish is native to the Americas, but Pilgrims called it “Indian pudding.” Sweetened with molasses and flavoured with nutmeg, what is it?

*

Late 1600s–1700s: Colonial Thanksgiving

The early Thanksgiving tables leaned heavily on local ingredients and practicality.

Dishes: Roasted meats (turkey made occasional appearances), stews, corn-based breads. Cranberries showed up, but only as unsweetened sauces or relishes. (Sugar wasn’t cheap, folks!)

✨ Fun Fact: Forks weren’t common yet—most colonial diners used spoons and knives, or their trusty hands.

🕵️ Trivia Puzzle: What is the name of the early sweet made from boiled molasses and stretched like taffy, popular at colonial gatherings?

*

1800s: A National Holiday Takes Shape

1846: Sarah Josepha Hale, editor of Godey’s Lady’s Book, campaigned for Thanksgiving to become a national holiday, romanticising turkey and pie in her prose.

1863: Abraham Lincoln made it official. Suddenly, turkey was the star of the show, with stuffing and mashed potatoes on the sidelines.

🦃 Fun Fact: Turkeys were chosen because they were plentiful, large, and didn’t lay eggs or produce milk (so, no guilt about eating future breakfasts).

🍰 Trivia Puzzle: What dessert, now synonymous with Thanksgiving, was considered a luxury due to its need for imported spices and sugar?

*

1940s: World War II and the Era of Cans

Wartime rationing shaped Thanksgiving tables. Fresh ingredients were scarce, so canned goods became staples.

Iconic additions: Green bean casserole (thank you, Campbell’s!), sweet potato casserole with marshmallows (a marketing gimmick).

Smaller turkeys: Big birds weren’t ration-friendly, leading to creative side dishes.

🥫 Fun Fact: Canned cranberry jelly debuted in the early 1940s—its wobbly charm still divides families today.

🍗 Trivia Puzzle: What kitchen device, a wartime invention, popularised deep-fried turkeys decades later?

*

1950s–60s: The Convenience Craze

TV dinners inspired shortcuts at the Thanksgiving table. Jell-O salads, pre-stuffed turkeys, and canned gravy reigned supreme.

Dish of the decade: Ambrosia salad—a psychedelic mix of fruit, marshmallows, and shredded coconut.

📺 Fun Fact: Thanksgiving dinners were often served earlier in the day, so families could watch football—a tradition launched in the 1950s.

🌈 Trivia Puzzle: What sweet, gelatinous treat was nicknamed “salad” despite having zero vegetables?

*

1970s–80s: Back to Basics

The counterculture movement brought Thanksgiving closer to its roots. Farm-to-table eating became fashionable again, with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

Trends: Heritage turkeys, rustic breads, roasted vegetables. Sweet potato casserole quietly retired its marshmallow topping (in most circles).

🌿 Fun Fact: The “Friendsgiving” concept unofficially began in this era as counterculture groups sought alternatives to traditional family gatherings.

🍠 Trivia Puzzle: This purple cousin of the sweet potato became a Thanksgiving trend after its debut in fusion cuisine. What is it?

*

2000s: Gourmet Thanksgiving

Foodie culture brought artisanal and chef-inspired touches to the table.

Trends: Brined, spatchcocked, or deep-fried turkeys; sourdough stuffing; heirloom squash.

Pumpkin spice: Took over pies, lattes, and even turkey brines (yes, really).

📷 Fun Fact: Thanksgiving dishes became Instagram art, from carefully styled pies to towering grazing boards.

📸 Trivia Puzzle: What hashtag, now ubiquitous, skyrocketed in the 2010s, inspiring food photography at every Thanksgiving table?

*

2010s–2020s: Plant-Based and Picture-Perfect

Vegan options went mainstream, with dishes like nut roasts and jackfruit “turkey.”

Trends: Truffle mac ’n’ cheese, charred Brussels sprouts, maple-glazed carrots.

Plant-based innovations: Tofurkey and lab-grown turkey-made niche debuts.

🌍 Fun Fact: In recent years, a growing number of families have adopted zero-waste Thanksgiving traditions, focusing on sustainability.

🍗 Trivia Puzzle: This tech-forward innovation, first announced in the 2010s, promises lab-grown, cruelty-free turkey for the Thanksgiving of the future. What is it?

From venison and porridge to Tofurkey and truffle oil, the Thanksgiving table reflects centuries of innovation, adaptation, and downright deliciousness. Whether you’re feasting on heritage recipes or photographing your perfect pie, one thing’s for sure—gratitude and great food will always be on the menu. How will you reinvent Thanksgiving next? The possibilities are as endless as the leftovers! 

***

Answers:

Indian pudding

Molasses candy (or pulled taffy)

Pumpkin pie

Propane turkey fryer

Jell-O salad

Ube (purple yam)

#Foodporn

Lab-grown meat